A demand letter is one of the most important documents in your car accident claim. It's your formal request to the insurance company for compensation, and it sets the tone for all negotiations that follow. A well-written demand letter can mean the difference between a lowball offer and a fair settlement.

This guide will show you exactly how to write an effective demand letter, what to include, and how to document your pain and suffering to maximize your compensation.

Key Statistics

Insurance companies settle over 95% of car accident claims before trial. Your demand letter is your best chance to establish the value of your case and anchor negotiations in your favor.

What Is a Car Accident Demand Letter?

A demand letter is a formal written document you send to the at-fault driver's insurance company that outlines your injuries, explains why their insured is liable, documents your damages, and states the amount of compensation you're seeking.

The demand letter serves several purposes:

Formally initiates the settlement negotiation process
Puts your claim on record with specific documentation
Demonstrates you're serious and prepared to pursue your case
Establishes an "anchor" for negotiations (your opening ask)
Shows the adjuster exactly what they're dealing with

Don't Skip This Step

Some claimants try to negotiate over the phone without a formal demand letter. This is a mistake. Insurance adjusters handle hundreds of claims. A written demand forces them to take your case seriously and creates a paper trail that protects you.

When to Send Your Demand Letter

Timing is critical. Send your demand letter too early, and you might not know the full extent of your injuries. Send it too late, and you risk running up against the statute of limitations.

Wait Until You Reach Maximum Medical Improvement (MMI)

MMI is the point where your condition has stabilized and your doctor doesn't expect significant further improvement. This ensures you can accurately calculate all your damages, including future medical costs.

Know Your State's Deadline

Every state has a statute of limitations for car accident claims (typically 2-4 years). You must file a lawsuit before this deadline if negotiations fail. Send your demand letter with enough time to negotiate and file suit if needed.

State	Statute of Limitations
California, Texas, Arizona, Nevada	2 years
Colorado, Pennsylvania, Illinois	2 years
Utah	4 years
Nebraska	4 years

Recommended Timeline

Most claimants send their demand letter 2-6 months after the accident, once they've completed treatment or reached MMI. This gives you complete medical records while leaving ample time to negotiate.

What to Include in Your Demand Letter

A strong demand letter follows a specific structure. Include each of these elements:

Your Identifying Information

Include your full name, address, phone number, claim number (if assigned), and the date of the accident. Reference the at-fault driver's name and policy number.

Statement of Facts

Describe what happened in clear, factual terms. Include the date, time, location, and weather conditions. Explain exactly how the accident occurred and why the other driver was at fault. Reference the police report if one was filed.

Liability Argument

Clearly explain why their insured is legally responsible. Cite traffic laws they violated, witness statements, and any admissions of fault. If there's a police report assigning fault, reference it.

Description of Your Injuries

Detail every injury you sustained, from major to minor. Use medical terminology from your doctors' reports. Explain your treatment: emergency room visits, surgeries, physical therapy, medications, and ongoing care needs.

Pain and Suffering Narrative

This is where you bring your damages to life. Describe how your injuries have affected your daily life, work, relationships, sleep, mental health, and ability to enjoy activities you once loved. Be specific and honest.

Itemized Economic Damages

List every out-of-pocket expense:

Medical bills (itemized by provider)
Lost wages (with documentation)
Property damage (vehicle repairs/replacement)
Future medical expenses (if applicable)
Other expenses (transportation, home modifications, etc.)

Non-Economic Damages

State your claim for pain and suffering, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life, and any other non-economic damages. Explain how you calculated this amount.

Your Demand Amount

State the total compensation you're seeking. This should be higher than what you'll accept (to leave room for negotiation) but still reasonable and supported by your documentation.

Response Deadline

Give the insurance company a reasonable deadline to respond (typically 30 days). State that you reserve the right to pursue legal action if they fail to respond or negotiate in good faith.

Supporting Documentation

Attach copies of all supporting evidence: medical records and bills, police report, photos of injuries and vehicle damage, proof of lost wages, witness statements, and repair estimates.

Sample Car Accident Demand Letter Template

Below is a template structure you can adapt for your own demand letter. Personalize each section with your specific details.

[Your Name]
[Your Address]
[City, State ZIP]
[Phone Number]
[Email]

[Date]

[Insurance Company Name]
[Claims Department]
[Address]

RE: Claim Number: [XXXXX]
Insured: [At-Fault Driver's Name]
Date of Loss: [Accident Date]

Dear Claims Adjuster:

I am writing to formally demand compensation for injuries and damages I sustained in a car accident caused by your insured, [Driver Name], on [Date] at [Location].

STATEMENT OF FACTS

[Describe the accident in detail: what happened, how it happened, weather conditions, time of day, and why the other driver was at fault. Reference the police report.]

LIABILITY

[Explain why their insured is legally responsible. Cite specific traffic violations, negligent conduct, and supporting evidence.]

INJURIES AND MEDICAL TREATMENT

[Detail all injuries and treatment received. Use medical terminology.]

IMPACT ON MY LIFE

[Describe pain and suffering, emotional impact, effect on work, relationships, daily activities, and quality of life.]

DAMAGES

Economic Damages:
- Medical Expenses: $[Amount]
- Lost Wages: $[Amount]
- Property Damage: $[Amount]
- Other Expenses: $[Amount]
Total Economic Damages: $[Amount]

Non-Economic Damages (Pain & Suffering): $[Amount]

TOTAL DEMAND: $[Amount]

Please respond to this demand within thirty (30) days. If I do not receive a satisfactory response, I am prepared to pursue all legal remedies available to me.

Sincerely,
[Your Signature]
[Your Printed Name]

Enclosures: [List all attached documents]

Important

This is a simplified template. Your actual demand letter should be more detailed, especially the facts, injuries, and pain and suffering sections. Consider having an attorney review your letter before sending.

How to Document Pain and Suffering

Pain and suffering often represents the largest portion of a car accident settlement, but it's also the hardest to prove. Insurance companies will try to minimize this component. Strong documentation is your best defense.

Keep a Daily Pain Journal

Document your pain levels each day on a scale of 1-10. Note specific symptoms, activities you couldn't do, medications taken, and how you felt emotionally. This contemporaneous record is powerful evidence.

Document Everything You've Lost

Activities: Sports, hobbies, exercise routines you can't do anymore
Sleep: Insomnia, nightmares, difficulty getting comfortable
Work: Reduced productivity, missed opportunities, career impact
Relationships: Strain on family, inability to care for children
Mental health: Anxiety, depression, fear of driving, PTSD symptoms
Daily tasks: Cooking, cleaning, bathing, dressing difficulties

Get Statements from Others

Ask family members, friends, and coworkers to write statements describing how you've changed since the accident. Third-party observations are compelling evidence that's hard to dispute.

Calculating Pain and Suffering Damages

Insurance companies typically use one of two methods:

Multiplier Method

Your economic damages multiplied by 1.5 to 5 (depending on severity). A $20,000 claim with a 3x multiplier = $60,000 for pain and suffering.

Per Diem Method

A daily rate (often your daily wage) multiplied by the number of days affected. $150/day x 180 days = $27,000 for pain and suffering.

What's Your Pain and Suffering Worth?

SetCalc's AI analyzes your specific injuries, treatment, and circumstances to estimate fair compensation for pain and suffering based on similar cases. Get a free estimate in minutes.

Calculate My Settlement Value

Learn more in our complete Pain and Suffering Calculator Guide.

Common Demand Letter Mistakes to Avoid

These errors can weaken your claim and reduce your settlement:

✗

Demanding Too Little

Your initial demand sets the ceiling. Start higher than what you'll accept because the insurance company will negotiate down. Research similar cases to ensure your demand is reasonable but not undervalued.

✗

Being Emotional or Aggressive

Keep your tone professional and factual. Angry rants or accusations make you look unreasonable and can hurt your credibility if the case goes to trial.

✗

Missing Documentation

Every claim in your letter should have supporting evidence. Don't just state your medical bills total $15,000 — attach the itemized bills.

✗

Sending Too Early

If you haven't finished treatment, you can't accurately calculate your damages. Wait until you've reached MMI or have a clear prognosis for ongoing care.

✗

Exaggerating or Lying

Insurance companies investigate claims. If they catch you exaggerating, your credibility is destroyed. Stick to documented facts.

✗

Ignoring Comparative Fault

If you were partially at fault, acknowledge it (briefly) and explain why the other driver bears primary responsibility. Trying to hide your fault looks dishonest.

What Happens After You Send Your Demand Letter

Sending your demand letter is just the beginning of negotiations. Here's what to expect:

Wait for Response

The insurance company typically has 30 days to respond (or whatever deadline you set). If they don't respond, follow up in writing and note the deadline has passed.

Expect a Low Counteroffer

The insurance company's first response will almost certainly be lower than your demand — often 30-50% of what they're actually willing to pay. This is normal. Don't accept the first offer.

Counter Their Counter

Respond with a reasoned counter-offer. Explain why their offer is inadequate, referencing specific evidence from your demand letter. Move toward the middle gradually.

Negotiate Until Agreement

Settlement negotiations often go back and forth 3-5 times. Stay patient and professional. Know your minimum acceptable amount, but don't reveal it early.

Get It in Writing

Once you agree on an amount, the insurance company will send a settlement agreement and release form. Read it carefully before signing — once you sign, you can't ask for more.

When to Consider Legal Help

If negotiations stall, the insurance company is acting in bad faith, or your injuries are severe, consider consulting a personal injury attorney. Many offer free consultations and work on contingency (no fee unless you win).

Know your case value before you negotiate. Going into negotiations without knowing what your case is worth puts you at a disadvantage.

Get my free settlement estimate →

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should my demand letter be?

Most effective demand letters are 3-5 pages, plus attachments. Long enough to be thorough, short enough to be read. Focus on quality over quantity.

Should I send the letter myself or have a lawyer do it?

For minor accidents with straightforward liability, you can send it yourself. For serious injuries, disputed fault, or high-value claims, an attorney's letterhead often gets better results.

What if the insurance company ignores my demand letter?

Follow up in writing after your deadline passes. If they continue to ignore you, consult an attorney about filing a lawsuit. Sometimes the threat of litigation prompts a response.

How much should I demand?

Start with a number higher than what you'll accept, but grounded in evidence. Many experts suggest demanding 75-100% more than your minimum acceptable settlement to leave room for negotiation.

Can I send a demand letter without a lawyer?

Yes. There's no legal requirement to have an attorney. However, studies show that claimants with legal representation typically receive higher settlements, even after paying attorney fees.

Where should I send the demand letter?

Send it to the claims adjuster handling your case via certified mail with return receipt. This creates proof that they received it. Keep a copy for your records.

Know What Your Case Is Worth Before You Demand

Your demand letter is only as strong as your understanding of your case value. SetCalc's AI analyzes your accident, injuries, and state laws to provide an attorney-reviewed estimate.

Calculate My Settlement Estimate Free

Free • No obligation • Results in 3 minutes

Related Resources

Pain & Suffering Calculator Guide How Settlements Work General Personal Injury Demand Letter Guide Settlement vs Lawsuit

Are You An Attorney?

Use AI to estimate settlements for your clients with a SetCalc Professional account.

Learn More

Car Accident Demand Letter